This week I thought about inequality, the lottery of birth, and the idea of taxing the rich.
To be honest, I spend a lot of my life thinking about inequality, unfairness, and the lottery of birth so I’m not sure why it stands out particularly this week – there is no, one, event that has brought it to the fore. It could though have to do with the fact that the neighbourhood watch group is asking people to no longer provide food or other items to the ‘dustbin divers’ who do their rounds on a Monday night. It isn’t that they are trying to be cruel, their reasoning is rather that there are heightened incidents of crime on a Monday night, crime, they feel, that is either directly related to the people roaming the streets or indirectly through the heightened number of people walking the streets providing a form of cover for the criminals.
They believe that if residents stop providing an ‘incentive’ for these men and stop putting their dustbins out at night they will no longer visit the neighbourhood on a Monday night. I am not only, not so sure they’ll manage to get everyone in the neighbourhood to stick to their request – especially seeing as only a very small minority of the people in the neighbourhood care enough to even be members of the neighbourhood watch, but I’m not so sure I want to stop providing the little bit of help to the man who comes to my gate each week.
I’m sure there are people roaming the streets on a Monday night who may have criminal intent but, to me, tarring everyone with the same brush is wrong. All ‘my guy’ (for want of naming him on a public forum) wants to do is work, rather than simply asking for money, he asks if he can weed my pan-handle driveway or if there is anything else he can do to earn some, constantly asking me to keep my ears open for any work I may hear about. In fact, on the occasion where I have given him a pile of old clothes or books or a school bag for his children he has been robbed – on one occasion he was even stabbed when trying to defend the charity he had been afforded.
I’ve also been told of a situation where a house had been broken into and the ‘dustbin divers’ who had been treated kindly by one of the neighbours came to him to tell him who had done it and where they could be found. I’m not saying that I necessarily have a workable solution but I can’t help wondering why all these men should be labelled criminal and discriminated against, when all a lot of them are doing is trying through whatever means to provide for their families (in a way I would hate to have to do myself – those dustbins are rank!).
There are of course multiple historical reasons we face the levels of inequality we currently do, but at the same time many contemporary ones too – I saw a tweet recently that said: “Based on recent reports, over N$12.3 billion in public funds in Namibia has been reported as unaccounted for, stolen, or wasted due to financial mismanagement and corruption, largely between 2015 and early 2026”.
This ties in with a very brief conversation I had with a local economist during the week in which he explained how simply taxing the rich in Namibia will not solve the problem of inequality. According to him the base is too small, the tax burden already onerous, and their wealth not actually that high when measured against global figures. “The only option,” he says is “to grow … create jobs and ensure those earning nothing are reduced in number”.
When it comes to creating jobs though, my thoughts on the difficulty of setting up and running a small business, and how you ‘get taken for a ride’ by almost everyone are probably better saved for another week, so we’ll leave it there with just some of the many things I’ve thought about this week.